If fordham and ogbu were correct, the social sanctions for acting white should be most severe in places like the segregated school, where opportunities are most limited. The theory and empirical foundation of ogbu s scholarship, which some have mistakenly reduced to the acting white hypothesis, is fully presented and revisited in this posthumous collection of his new writings plus the works of over 20 scholars. The researchers suggested that black students socialize their peers into. Specifically, the study looked at more than one or two school environments including eight north carolina schools in its sample, a rarity in this line of research, in order to get a clearer sense of whether an oppositional culture truly exists. Ogbu s research that popularized the phrase acting white in the mid1980s to help explain why black students might disdain behaviors associated with high achievement, like. Through the integration of these various ideas, fordham and ogbu contended that african americans faced the burden of acting white if they espoused academic successa behavior said to be the domain of white americans. Some of the questions that ogbu asked himself and which others asked him include the following. Black students interviewed in this book almost never say, there is no such thing as acting white. The acting white hypothesis gained widespread attention in the media as an explanation for black academic underachievement. The question of whether or not acting white attitudes are prevalent has been debated in academic literature. In their 2005 study, tyson, darity and castellino 2005 sought to contribute to the debate about the burden of acting white. In this article, the author reports the voices of four academically successful african american men, in their early 20s, as they explicitly respond, in retrospect, to questions regarding the applicability of the burden of acting white theory to their schooling experiencesresponses made after reading research articles written by signithia fordham and john ogbu. Collective identity and the burden of acting white in black.
He is also revising a book for publication by the russell sage foundation based on the quantitative part of the study that included some 2,400 students see also ogbu 1995a, n. Black adolescents have learned a welldefined fear of acting white. Collective identity and the burden of acting white in black history, community, and education john u. Coping with the burden of acting white by signithia fordham and john.
This study used a phenomenological qualitative approach that engaged black students in discussions about the burden of acting white and its impact on their inschool and postschool outcomes and. One explanation the authors offer will make sense to anyone who has ever seen a john hughes movie. Two highprofile studies ainsworthdarnell and downey 1998. It brings together in one volume, for the first time, some of the most critical works on these issues as well as examples of programs aimed at re. Moreover, these negative, defeatist attitudes are passed on to their youth who develop an oppositional culture of what. The results of my studies, of course, point in precisely the opposite direction. Curatore edito da routledge a febbraio 2008 ean 9780805851038.
A 1986 ethnographic study by signithia fordham and john ogbu sparked controversy among education researchers by suggesting an acting white effect could be a source of the black white achievement gap in u. Reframing the debate on black student achievement horvat, erin mcnamara, oconnor, carla on. John ogbu s ethnographic research and is commonly used to explain presentday achievement gaps between black and white students. Physical activity and fruit and vegetable intake among black and white female college students at two and fouryear colleges and universities. Collective identity and the burden of acting white in black history, community, and education collective identity and the burden of acting white in black history, community, and education ogbu, john 20041020 00. Rather, it appears to develop in some schools under certain conditions that seem to contribute to animosity between high and lowachieving students within or between racial and socioeconomic groups. Collective identity and the burden of acting white in. Collective identity and the burden of acting white in black history, community, and education. In contrast to the previous literature ainsworthdarnell and downey, 1998, cook and ludwig, 1997, fig. The burden of acting white, tyson flashcards quizlet. His work with signithia fordham 1986 helped popularize concepts such as the burden of acting white and black oppositional identity, and his career culminated with a stunning text, black americans in an affluent suburb.
Ogbu characterizes this initial blockage of educational equity as the catalyst for moving blacks away from more sought after career roles accessible to whites as adults. The focus of this analysis is the resulting conflict experienced. Oct 29, 2014 there are a lot of things about black culture that are criticized, but acting white is a fascinating hypothesis for me perhaps because i see the parallels in india. Ogbu s theory is further expanded by introducing the concept of the burden of acting white fordham and ogbu 1986 into the framework. Fictive kinship is proposed as a framework for understanding how a sense of collective identity enters into the process of schooling and affects academic achievement. We are grateful to george akerlof, pol antras, david card, prudence carter, kenneth chay, william darity. Beyond internalized racism and the burden of acting white abstract theorists posit that the social reinforcement of racially oppressive assumptions eventually works its way into. The notion that acting white is simply attributable to selfsabotage is even less persuasive. The myth about smart black kids and acting white that. This paper employs the idea of acting white to describe the contradictory nature of schooling for black children, and their concurrent embracement ard rejection of those behaviors defined as acting white, utilizing supportive data from my recent research and other sources to support this. The importance of peer groups in managing academic success erin mcnamara horvat temple university kristine s.
For example, in their widelycited 1986 article entitled black students school success. What president obama gets wrong about acting white the. Minority status, oppositional culture, and schooling. In 1986, nigerian sociologist john ogbu coauthored with signithia fordham coauthored a study that concluded that highperforming africanamerican students in a washington, d. A study of academic disengagement is an important book for a wide range of researchers, professionals, and students, particularly in the areas of black education, minority education, comparative and international education, sociology of education, educational anthropology, educational policy. The acting white theory originated in the 1980s with dr. Fordham, signithia black adolescents have learned a welldefined fear of acting white. A study of academic disengagement 2003, in which he showed that both lowincome and middleclass black.
Black peoples disdain for proper english and academic achievement is a myth. Policy and programmatic implications are discussed. So where does the idea of the burden of acting white come from. Coping with the burden of acting white signithia fordham and john u. The data suggest that school structures, rather than culture, may help explain when this stigma becomes racialized, producing a burden of acting white for black adolescents, and when it becomes classbased, producing a burden of acting high and mighty for lowincome whites.
Our empirical analysis of acting white uncovers a rich set of new facts. This book is the definitive and final presentation of john ogbu s cultural ecological model and the many debates that his work has sparked during the past decade. Feb 15, 2008 minority status, oppositional culture, and schooling examines content, methodological, and policy issues framing the debate on academic achievement, school engagement, and oppositional culture. In their widelynoted 1986 article, black students school success. Signithia fordham and john ogbu, though, introduced the idea in the academic literature. See other formats bocmht resume ed 281 948 ud 025 503 author fordham signithia titte black students school success. Parkss recent death and a conference held jointly at the university of north carolina at chapel hill and duke university called acting white revisiting ogbu and fordhams sic hypothesis on october 28 and 29, 2005, i am reminded of the controversy that followed the publication of my article with john u. This book is the definitive and final presentation of john ogbus cultural ecological model and the many debates that his work has sparked during the past decade.
Coping with the burden of acting white, signithia fordham and the late john ogbu contended that one important reason for academic underachievement among african american youth is the overarching, cultural devaluation of educational attainment within black communities. Eric is an online library of education research and information, sponsored by the institute of education sciences ies of the u. John uzo ogbu may 9, 1939 20 august 2003 was a nigerianamerican anthropologist and professor known for his theories on observed phenomena involving race and intelligence, especially how race and ethnic differences played out in educational and economic achievement. The theory and empirical foundation of ogbu s scholarship, which some have mistakenly reduced to the acting white hypothesis, is. The study, which was widely dispersed and is still relevant today, attributed black students lower academic achievement to the association between doing well in school and acting white. The acting white phenomena, as it occurs, is not responsible for black academic underachievement, nor is it reflective of a broad cultural frame of reference, as fordham and ogbu 1986 suggest. They responded using the burden of acting white which suggested that minority students do perform well in school. Peer support for african american male college achievement.
John u ogbu this book is the definitive and final presentation of john ogbus cultural ecological model and the many debates that his work has sparked during the past decade. They now suggest the importance of considering black peoples expressive responses to their historical status and experience in america. Ogbu pointed out that there are high achieving blacks that did not adopt the oppositional theory. Ogbu died soon after it was released, and the original. Specifically, i summarize the evolution of oppositional collective identity and cultural frame of reference or oppositional culture among black americans and discuss the black experience with the burden of acting white in the contemporary united states. Fordham and john ogbu published black students school success. The burden of acting white cannot be attributed specifically to black culture. Beren professor of economics harvard university and nber july 2009.
Ogbu s own chapters present how his ideas about minority education and culture developed. Black american students in an affluent suburb sociocultural. School success and african american male students david w. Though the notion is far older, acting white to my knowledge first entered academic discourse with a 1986 paper by signithia fordham and john u. Lewis hamilton college in 1986 fordham and ogbu introduced the idea that black students continue to underperform in school because of their cultural opposition to acting white. Subordinate minorities like black americans develop a sense of collective identity or sense of peoplehood in opposition to the social identity of white americans because. To explain black students underachievement we must consider black peoples expressive responses to their historical status and experience in america. Beyond internalized racism and the burden of acting white. In 1986 signithia fordham coauthored, along with ogbu, a study which concluded that some african american students in a washington, d. The theory and empirical foundation of ogbu s scholarship, which some have. Cook and ludwig 1998, both using data from the national educational longitudinal study nels, found little evidence of either an oppo sitional culture or a burden of acting white among black adolescents. Beyond internalized racism and the burden of acting white shaun r. Acting white roland fryers research reported in the last issue of education next acting white research, winter 2006 uses a large nationally representative data set and innovative statistical methods to show convincingly that black students in racially integrated public schools have fewer friends if they earn as than if they earn b.
Minority status, oppositional culture, and schooling examines content, methodological, and policy issues framing the debate on academic achievement, school engagement, and oppositional culture. The authors support their argument with ethnographic data from a high school in washington, d. Fordham and ogbu 1986 further formalize the link between racial discrimi nation, acting white, and educational outcomes. Coping with the burden of acting white, signithia fordham and john ogbu propose that one significant reason for academic underachievement among black youth is a broad cultural devaluation of educational attainment within african american communities. Acting white featured story rochester city newspaper.
Minority status, oppositional culture, and schooling ebook. This book never says or can prove that ogbu was absolutely wrong. Much of this work originated from fordham and ogbus 1986 acting white hypothesis, which. Fictive kinship is proposed as a framework for understanding how. When smart black kids try hard and do well, they are picked on by their less successful peers for acting white. Jul 24, 2014 the concept of acting white gained traction with a 1986 research paper called black students school success. No one ever denies that on average foreign blacks seem to like school and excel at it better than longstanding black americans. He suggested that being a castelike minority affects motivation and achievement, depressing iq scores. Ogbu further echoed these findings in his 2003 book black american students in an affluent. Africanamerican attitudes toward higher education and their struggle with collective identity and the burden of acting white by frederick laron cope a thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in the department of english in the graduate school of the university of alabama. The myth about smart black kids and acting white that wont.
It is simply one of many possible coping responses to feelings of devaluation that black youth encounter. The theory and empirical foundation of ogbus scholarship, which some have mistakenly reduced to the acting white hypothesis, is. The concept of acting white gained traction with a 1986 research paper called black students school success. Berg, sherell brown goodwin, erin stratton, kincaid lowe, linda grimsley, jan rodd, catherine williams, cheri mattox, bruce foster. Ogbu s theory of academic disengagement 387 left them with a negative model of folk success, and a pessimistic view of the labor market as having a racially stratified job ceiling. Ogbus own chapters present how his ideas about minority education and culture developed. The theory and empirical foundation of ogbus scholarship, which some have mistakenly reduced to the acting white hypothesis, is fully presented and revisited in this posthumous collection of his new writings plus the works of over 20 scholars. An empirical analysis of acting white sciencedirect.
1425 1230 746 1360 315 1577 769 885 1644 217 395 1259 1529 492 872 635 1313 223 1307 764 30 315 186 1423 612 948 923 1153 1039 411 1411 679 1025 154 840 1165 50 782 1338 57 336 1158 1407 1005 686 1280 111